top of page
Staff Writer

The Paradox of Biden's Economy and Electoral Struggles

In the clash between economic prosperity and political turmoil, Joe Biden finds himself ensnared in a paradoxical struggle for reelection.

Despite presiding over what many consider the strongest economy in U.S. history, Joe Biden finds himself in the precarious position of trailing in his reelection bid. The jobless rate has lingered below 4 percent for over two years, with wage growth outpacing that of the previous administration. Inflation has cooled, bolstering consumer purchasing power. Yet, Biden's approval languishes below 40 percent, with a disapproval rating of 56 percent. Donald Trump leads in key swing states, and there's speculation he may even secure the popular vote, especially by gaining traction with Black and Latino voters in Democratic-leaning regions.


This disconcerting reality has thrown Democratic campaign strategists into a panic, prompting soul-searching about what it means when a sitting president struggles to win reelection amid a robust economy, especially when voters prioritize economic concerns.


The disconnect between economic indicators and public sentiment has two primary causes: a nuanced perception of economic health and a shifting focus away from economic issues altogether. While headline numbers boast low unemployment and wage growth, they fail to capture the financial strain felt by many due to high interest rates, soaring costs of essentials like housing and cars, and persistent inflation in consumer goods.


Moreover, Americans' views on the economy are heavily influenced by partisan biases and media consumption. Republicans often perceive economic downturns under Democratic leadership, while Democrats view Republican-led economies negatively. This polarization distorts objective assessments of economic performance.


Even among Democrats, skepticism about the economy persists. Many liberals, bombarded by negative news, feel little personal improvement and are concentrated in high-cost coastal areas. Economic indicators hint at a fragile outlook, with rising debt and declining leading indicators in some sectors, adding to public unease.


However, the stock market thrives, millennials gain wealth, and low-wage workers see income growth. Despite these positives, voter sentiment remains unchanged, reflecting a historical tendency to focus more on downturns than upturns.


Interestingly, economic factors seem less influential in shaping political sentiment. Gas prices, once a key indicator, no longer strongly correlate with presidential approval. As material well-being improves, voters prioritize values over economic issues, such as environmental protection and social justice.


Additionally, growing partisan polarization diminishes the economy's electoral impact, as voters increasingly align with their party regardless of economic performance. This leaves a small group of persuadable voters, disaffected by both parties, who may be swayed by exceptional candidates or heightened stakes.


Ultimately, neither Trump nor Biden may benefit from a strong economy, suggesting that economic prowess alone is insufficient to secure reelection in an era of deepening political divisions and evolving voter priorities.

bottom of page